[The  third  operation on my left hip  lowered my   inspiration and energy the past several months.  But I have now recovered enough to continue with this blog/memoir.  The startup will be slow but, I  hope, steady.] 

At the beginning of the MACCORMICKS, I explained that I would defer writing on the remarkable John MacDonald and Professor Donald Neil  MacCormick (grandson and great grandson of NEIL TORMORE)  story because they had been well  covered over the years in many media forms.

But two recent pieces in The Times (Scotland edition)  and The Herald  convinced me to break my planned order of presentation.  Both stories  extolled the many accomplishments of Professor Neil in the scholarly and political worlds.    And both ended with a description of  a campaign of the University of Edinburgh Law School to honour him in a quite unique way – by having four busts of Neil to be made by a well known sculptor, two placed at the entrance to the Law School and the others placed in two institutions in the City. The Law School web site follows:


The University of Edinburgh Law SchoolEnlighten…


Neil MacCormick Sculpture Fund

Help us create a lasting legacy to Professor Sir Neil MacCormick

Edinburgh Law School seeks to produce a collection of four busts, created by Kenny Hunter, generating a lasting tribute to Sir Neil MacCormick’s outstanding contribution to intellectual life in Scotland. Two of the busts will frame the refurbished Law School main entrance reflecting the duality of his life in academia and public affairs. The remaining single busts will be displayed at the Royal Society of Edinburgh and the Scottish National Portrait Gallery.

Donate to the Neil MacCormick Sculpture Fund here

Neil MacCormick bust front view Neil MacCormick bust side view Neil MacCormick bust back view
Casts of the sculptures by Kenny Hunter.

Read the proposal by sculptor Kenny Hunter for more information on the background to the sculptures

Professor Sir Neil MacCormick: A life in and beyond Old College

Neil MacCormick with book

Neil MacCormick was a great colleague and friend to many at Edinburgh Law School. Appointed to the Regius Chair of Public Law and the Law of Nature and Nations in 1972, he held this position until his retirement in January 2008  – more than half of his life.

An eminent figure in  academia and beyond, he made a significant contribution to legal philosophy and public affairs over 30 years.

The author of nine books and countless articles, his body of work is richly versatile. From his earliest publications, he forged a strong link between the ‘positivist’ emphasis on law’s social foundations and his commitment to a philosophy grounded in the democratic right of collective self-government.

Neil was adept at illustrating theory by practical example. He wrote with flair and insight about matters as diverse as statutory interpretation, judicial precedent, children’s rights, the right to die, official secrecy, obscenity, intellectual property and the relationship between domestic and international law. His style was engaging yet challenging, his tone conversational yet precise, his temper sometimes critical but always constructive.

“With the death of Neil MacCormick, the World loses one of those great minds and fantastic persons that make Humankind so precious. Scotland loses its best thinker since the Enlightened Philosophers and Europe loses a powerful intellectual vision of peace, solidarity and self-determination.”

Joxerramon Bengoetxea

Neil MacCormick in seminar 1970s

Neil’s intellectual curiosity and the depth of his involvement in public affairs meant that his legal philosophy was always a work in progress. Of the four later books produced under the rubric of Law, State and Practical Reason that provide an eloquent and lasting statement of his mature thought, Questioning Sovereignty (1999) is the most obvious link to his active political philosophy. It makes a path-breaking contribution to understanding the overlapping character of contemporary state, supranational (European Union) and sub-state (Scottish) law and politics, challenging the adequacy of a traditional conception of  sovereignty and national citizenship.

Neil’s academic accomplishment, and great service to the University and Law school (including two stints as Dean), was matched outside of Old College. He learned many lessons of liberal nationalism and active citizenship from  his father,  the founder of the modern Scottish nationalist movement. His subsequent contribution to the nationalist cause was immense. He was a leading SNP visionary for many years, playing a key part in reconciling the gradualist and fundamentalist wings of the Party. He penned a draft constitution for an independent Scotland, and made a persuasive case for a new state’s automatic membership of the European Union. He served with distinction as an Member of the  European Parliament in Brussels from 1999-2004. In 2007 he was appointed special adviser on European and External Affairs to Alex Salmond, the first SNP First Minister. This was a position he held until his death.

The two separate strands in Neil’s life ran in close harmony. This was as much about sensibility as substance.

As thinker and teacher he was always closely engaged with practical questions. In Edinburgh and internationally he did much to improve the standing of legal philosophy as an active component of a professional legal education rather than a niche field of interest. As a politician and public speaker, he retained the best of the academic tradition. His approach was inclusive rather than divisive, reasoned rather than emotive, open-minded rather than partisan, long-sighted rather than seeking immediate advantage.

“One story to illustrate the manner and style of Neil’s teaching, which also shows the nature of the man. In the 1975-76 session he arrived in Room 270 Old College to deliver a lecture to the class of Jurisprudence. As he took to the podium he removed from his wrist with a characteristic flourish what was evidently a lady’s watch. This produced catcalls from members of his audience. Neil smiled, explained that having broken his own watchstrap that morning he had borrowed his wife’s watch so that he could keep to his allotted 50 minutes with the class, and then used the class reaction to analyse the difference between social rules (men’s watches aren’t the same as women’s ones, lectures last for 50 minutes not the hour in the timetable) and legal rules. All that had been abstract and difficult for jurisprudence novitiates suddenly became pellucidly clear. Either Neil had thought it all out before, in which case the expansive gesture with which he removed the watch was perfectly timed to get the reaction he wanted; or, more likely, it was unplanned but he could react with instant humour to an unexpected situation, engage with his audience, and turn the whole thing intellectually to support what he had anyway wanted to say. Whichever, it was a brilliant moment of theatre that remains vivid in the memory nearly 35 years later. “

Professor Hector MacQueen

Neil won many of the glittering prizes. He was awarded a number of honorary degrees; he was three time recognized as the Scottish ‘MEP of the Year’; he was knighted in 2001 for his services to scholarship in law , and in 2004 he received the Royal Society of Edinburgh’s Royal Gold Medal for  Outstanding Achievement. Yet he remained an essentially modest, kind and generous man – someone who treated his many talents as their own reward and used them as best he could to enhance the many lives he touched.

Neil died on 5th April 2009. He was survived by his three children and by his second wife Flora, who remains a cherished friend of the Law School.





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: